I have started and stopped this post dozens of times. It's a touchy subject. People have strong feelings about God, whether they ardently believe or steadfastly don't believe, and I have felt fearful about dipping my toe into these waters. Part of the problem, the reason for all the starting and stopping, is I'm still figuring out how I feel about it all.
For most of my life, God was this unknown entity I thought about only in church. As a child, I would kneel and fold my hands with the rest of the congregation, peeking out of the corner of my eye to get the pose just right. I would close my eyes and think: Um, hello? God? I don't know if you can hear me, but if you can I just wanted to say, well, HI.
During the prayers for the departed, I would diligently name everyone I had ever known who passed away, thinking: God, could you please look out for them? They are really special.
And then I got sober, and all the talk about a Higher Power got me thinking: what does God mean to me?
People would talk about their Higher Power, and it didn't scare me or produce any feelings of cynicism. What I mostly felt was curiosity. I would hear people talk about their Higher Power like a good friend or loving parent, and I would wonder how do they DO that? How do they just talk to their Higher Power like he is on the other end of some divine telephone line?
Over time, I figured out what was wrong. I stumble over the word God. Not in a does-He-exist-or-doesn't-He kind of way. It's just that the word God always produces a mental picture of a man in flowing robes and a long white beard sitting on a cloud with a ferocious, inaccessible look on his face. I probably saw it in a picture book, or in Sunday School, and the image stuck.
So I tried to let go of any pre-conceived notions I had of God. It only sort of worked, partly because I couldn't lose a ritualistic feeling around prayer. I would kneel to pray and I would spend the whole time wondering if I was doing it right. Was I fervent enough? Was I allowed to do this if I wasn't sure about my feelings about God?
I've been reading a lot of texts about Buddhism, and I'm really drawn to it. Buddhism, to me, revolves around acceptance, compassion and nurturing an ability to live in the moment, to accept what life dishes your way instead of trying to control or alter reality.
What I learn in my program of recovery and through Buddhist teachings helps me understand that what I crave is spirituality, as opposed to religion. I bristle at the dogma of religion, the idea that there is a right way and a wrong way to communicate with God. I've never been comfortable with the notion of Heaven or Hell - to me it has always placed pressure on doing it right, like I won't be allowed entry into the afterlife if I don't follow a certain set of rules.
I heard this expression, which is somewhat tongue-in-cheek but rang true for me: religion is for people who don't want to go to Hell, and spirituality is for people who have been to Hell and are looking for a way out of it.
Active alcoholism was so all about me - about my pain, my ego, my self-esteem (or lack thereof), my fears. Spirituality, for me, is the pathway away from the self-centered fear of rejection; it leads me towards compassion, towards acceptance of myself and others.
I pray all the time. I don't worry about who I'm praying to anymore. It doesn't matter, really. I give my will over to a kind of Divine Spirit, having faith that life isn't about a blueprint of right or wrong, that life is about millions of moments, and inside each moment is an opportunity to commune with compassion and love.
And you know what? It works. I focus my energies away from self, away from Ego. When I pray, I don't pray for outcomes as much as energies. I pray for guidance to do the next right thing. I pray for compassion, gratitude and enthusiam. Most importantly, to me, I pray for acceptance. When I'm trying to bend the world to suit my needs, I'm moving away from compassion, away from love, away from the Divine.
Surrendering my will, getting out of my own way, has produced so many miracles in my life. When I'm not trying to force the world to yield to my desires, I'm pleasantly surprised all the time. When life gets hard, when I'm faced with a challenge I don't think I can overcome, I think: Oh yeah. I don't have to overcome it, because it's not up to me. If I get out of the way and focus on gratitude, acceptance and doing the next right thing - moment to moment - my molehills don't become mountains. Problems that seem unresolvable settle into solutions, bit by bit, that I couldn't ever have imagined.
Now, I believe this to be true: the world gives you back exactly what you put into it.
If I'm putting negativity, pain and anger into the world, that is what I will receive in return. If I'm putting compassion, light and love into the world, then I'm getting compassion, light and love back.
I may not fully understand how I feel about God, and that's okay. What I do know, now, is that I believe. I believe in the energies that flow around and through us all.
Edited to add: I would really love to hear from you. If you have thoughts about all this, please share. I promise I'm not grubbing for comments -- I'm truly curious to hear other persepectives on this - it helps me to learn more.
Oh Ellie. I wish it didn't sound so hollow or cliche to say that, in this area, you and I are so, so alike. I have stopped and started writing about it many times as well, but haven't got it to a solid post yet. Just... well, just know that all I can say is I agree with and identify with everything, everything you just said, 100 percent. ♥
ReplyDeleteFantastic!
ReplyDeleteI love this post! I share a lot of your beliefs and feelings about religion and spirituality. When I was in college I took an Eastern Philosophy class and learned a lot about Buddhism. As you stated, writing about God is a very touchy subject but I think you handled it really well.
ReplyDeleteI was raised catholic. but that didn't work too well for me being born out of wedlock and told from a very young age by relatives I was going to hell. I joined another christian church in my 20s and served a mission and that worked for me for awhile and then I started to feel bitter and angry about all the things everyone kept saying I needed (a husband and children) to be fully a part of the religion that I didn't (and might never) have. so...since then I've been leaning more toward buddhism. (growing up my mother had some issues with the catholic church too so we attended many churches including those with seances and healing services, we also have jewish and other in our family). it feels good. we all work to help ourselves and thereby others to feel good. to me its about letting go of what others think - about you, about life, and figuring out what YOU think and believe and mostly, enjoying all the good that life is. and I think THAT is a great philosophy.
ReplyDeleteWhat I believe about God is that He-She "read" your post and agrees with you. You expressed Belief so well. Thank you!
ReplyDeleteWell said! (I was going to say Amen!, but then thought it might be considered uncouth...)
ReplyDeleteI have had similar thoughts as you. I was raised in a church where making sure you looked the part meant a lot. I was always so jealous of people who went to church and felt enlightened or comforted. I always felt so intimidated in church, myself-- thinking I was doing or feeling something wrong.
Over several years, I've been able to come to my own conclusions-- and it was spirituality, not religion! Anyone may take comfort in certain religious practices (mass, or revivals, or pagan sabbats), and that's fine by me, but it took something different for me to feel connected to the divine. Since I want acceptance for my path, I give acceptance and tolerance to others in theirs. I think (hope, dare I say it-- pray) that this is the best, most powerful gift I can give them.
You did a fabulous job with this post. Honestly. It's such a difficult subject to talk about, but you did it so well. I can relate to so much of what you've said.
ReplyDeleteI feel very similar to you. I don't like the way "God" has been taken over, and I also don't like thinking of that force as a "he." Why not a "she," dammit?
ReplyDeleteBut even "she" doesn't work, because God shouldn't have a gender. God just is.
A friend told me recently, as soon as you try to put words around this idea of "God," the whole magic of it disappears. I think she's right. "God" is an experience we have of being human, to search for something divine, to want to feel connected to it.
I really believe in the idea of energy. Prayer is a way of setting your intention, connecting your conscious self with your unconscious self. Yoga has helped me be spiritual, and then I became a Quaker, which in my meeting, has few rules and is more about each person's individual journey. I love hearing about others' journeys. That's the best ministry I can find.
Well, I love discussing religion, so this post is right up my alley:) Very interesting and thought-provoking. I am an Orthodox Jew, so I do believe there's a "right way," but I also believe that G-d puts people in situations for a reason, and we all have different paths to follow. Let me know if that doesn't make any sense!
ReplyDeleteThanks for this interesting post, Ellie. I'm Jewish too and the child of two Holocaust Survivors, which somehow didn't kill off my belief in God as a young child! For some reason, and despite my parents' atheism after the war, I always felt the presence of God in my life. I was also relieved to find out when studying my own religion later that Jewish belief states that God has a female presence and a male presence.
ReplyDeleteAs a twelve-stepper too I've seen many miracles occur in my life. I've always been absolutely in love with being Jewish but I will say that through program my amazement at the power of God increases all the time. I am blessed, both as a Jew religiously and as a spiritual being.
Great insights, everyone. Thank you for sharing your thoughts!
ReplyDeleteOne of the things I like so much about Buddhism, and it parallels with the things I learn in my recovery program, is that you can intertwine your core faith with the principals of acceptance and compassion - there is a great quote by the Dalai Lama about how people of all faiths are able to integrate these things into their lives. So it's not like I have to 'become' Buddhist to benefit from their teachings.
It's like that for me in recovery, too. The things I practice in recovery (or try to) like compassion, surrender, acceptance and living in the moment are additive to my core faith.
Loving these comments and different views. Please keep them coming!
-Ellie
I'm an atheist and one of the reasons AA doesn't work for me is because I do not believe in any higher power.
ReplyDeleteBut I still loved this post. I love the way you describe your own feelings and progress towards contentment. There is so much to learn here, despite my own lack of belief, I still feel a real affinity with the things you write.
You are truly my soul sober sister.. been struggling with this God topic for awhile now and purchased two "Buddhism and the Twelve steps" books a few days ago. Tentatively planning some kind of study group around the topic of Buddhism and recovery.. have a few interested parties, perhaps you are?? "One Breath at a Time" by Kevin Griffin is quite good on the subject (ordered it used through Amazon). As always, love your posting..thanks!
ReplyDeleteWe've talked about this a little bit, I think...and I never really know how to articulate my take on this. I try to be careful because I know that Christians in general have given themselves a really bad name. I'm a Christian and I've been frustrated with Christianity (the religion) my entire life. And yet the humble, accepting and compassionate Christ-man still remains. When I strip away the religion of Christianity and keep the spirituality, I believe it reflects what you're saying about Buddhism.
ReplyDeleteThat's why I love Brennan Manning's work so much, the way he strips Christianity of what it's become and holds fast to grace and unconditional love.
The reality is that AA, in its beginnings, was based in Christianity. Dr Bob and Bill were basically bible thumpers. And I love that they (and the other people taking part in AA's beginning) did not keep it restrictive, that they allowed it to flow out to touch anyone and everyone. I think that's how Jesus would have it. He was known for simply accepting people exactly as they were/are in that very moment. I don't know why Christians can't do the same, with no expectation for a more Christianized version of the person in the future. If that makes sense.
Love your thoughts, as always.
I'm so glad you started this post for a thirteenth time! Beautifully written, relevant, and open-minded, Ellie. I share many of your sentiments - thank you for putting it all into words so easily understood.
ReplyDeletethis is such a gorgeous post. I've been trying to come to terms with what God is to me too these past couple years. I've finally decided (for now, at least) that God isn't a person, or a Model for Man, or whatever. God isn't a He, or a She, God is an It. it. I don't think the capitalization is important.
ReplyDeletemy "God" is the thing/force that spurs all the energy in the entire universe into something useful. It's the stuff that makes that makes the flowers grow and the breeze blow and our heart start. It's all the stuff that fills in the spaces where nothing seems to be.
I was raised in a very Catholic city as a never Baptized child. It was pretty difficult. I am now Catholic although there are many things I don't agree with in that religion. For me, it's the formality, history, and traditions that really speak to me. Which is very unlike me normally, I am not a formal, traditional person necessarily.
ReplyDeleteAs far as what I actually believe: I truly believe God accepts us all for who we are if we are "good" people. He sees our faults and troubles and while he may not think we are making the right decisions, he is following us through life.
He does not accept hate, whether it's from a "Christian", Muslim, Atheist, or anyone else. He knows we are all going to falter, but at the end it's how we live our life. It's not going to make a difference whether or not I went to confession right before I die or whether someone is "saved". It's how we live our lives. If we are loving, generous people who give of ourselves and do the best we can, he's going to accept us.
In the end, does anyone honestly know that their religion is the only one? I don't think so. I think that comes from me not being raised with the idea of faith. I know many people whose faith is as much a part of them as their eye color and I envy that a little, but I will never quite be there. I hope that what I believe will matter, but who knows!
I thought it was interesting that you mentioned Buddhism. My father became a Buddhist after he quit drinking. It brought him much peace and continues to do so.
I could totally keep writing, but I am going to do you and your readers a favor and quit. I'm also not going to go back and read this before I hit post because I'll chicken out so I apologize for any typos!
Hi Ellie,
ReplyDeleteI believe that Jesus/God loves me. That is the foundation of my Spirituality. I have rejected most organized religion. My mother (the Organist) would tip over if she knew I no longer attended church.
Anyway, someone once said, "The biggest barrier to Christ are Christians". (sorry don't know the author) So true. I have been hurt endless times by well-meaning and not-so-well meaning Christians. It has taken me many years to not create God in the image of either myself or other imperfect Christians.
It wasn't until after treatment, AA, admitting, submitting and comitting that I have discovered with-in myself a willingness to love God and perhaps more importantly a willingness to allow myself to be loved by God.
I love Brennan Manning too. He writes simply and speaks to my alcoholic heart. He says...
"I want neither a terrorist spirituality that keeps me in a perpetual state of fright about being in right relationship with my heavenly Father nor a sappy spirituality that portrays God as such a benign teddy bear that there is no aberrant behavior or desire of mine that he will not condone. I want a relationship with the Abba of Jesus, who is infinitely compassionate with my brokenness and at the same time an awesome, incomprehensible, and unwieldy Mystery. "
--Brennan Manning
Another Brennan Manning fan here, too!
ReplyDeleteWhere I live most recovery people make a point of saying they are spiritual not religious. I often wonder why they feel the need to make that point. Why can't we all just live out our beliefs? Then I remember how many times I want to make sure others know I am not like them, whoever "them" happens to be in the moment.
And in this case it's I'm not like them people who say they are spiritual not religious cause I'm religious. Sigh. Big sigh. See. I end up seeing me in just about anyone if I look hard enough.
Kudos for you for tackling a touchy subject. AA has taught me that God is a big God with room enough for all.
Your comments are all so interesting and informative - THANK YOU. And I'm definitely going to read Brennan Manning! See? I knew you guys would have terrific input.
ReplyDeleteAnd Hope, I loved this: "Why can't we all just live out our beliefs?"
Such a simple statement, and so loaded with meaning. Faith shouldn't be about my beliefs vs. anyone elses... but so often I feel back on my heels defending myself. And I shouldn't We ARE all free to live out our beliefs, and if we could do this harmoniously the world would certainly be a better place.
-Ellie
Oh, and Kate (kmsanborn): that study group would be SO interesting to me! And I'm going to get the Kevin Griffin book, too. Thank you!
ReplyDeletethis is such a gorgeous post. I've been trying to come to terms with what God is to me too these past couple years. I've finally decided (for now, at least) that God isn't a person, or a Model for Man, or whatever. God isn't a He, or a She, God is an It. it. I don't think the capitalization is important.
ReplyDeletemy "God" is the thing/force that spurs all the energy in the entire universe into something useful. It's the stuff that makes that makes the flowers grow and the breeze blow and our heart start. It's all the stuff that fills in the spaces where nothing seems to be.
I feel very similar to you. I don't like the way "God" has been taken over, and I also don't like thinking of that force as a "he." Why not a "she," dammit?
ReplyDeleteBut even "she" doesn't work, because God shouldn't have a gender. God just is.
A friend told me recently, as soon as you try to put words around this idea of "God," the whole magic of it disappears. I think she's right. "God" is an experience we have of being human, to search for something divine, to want to feel connected to it.
I really believe in the idea of energy. Prayer is a way of setting your intention, connecting your conscious self with your unconscious self. Yoga has helped me be spiritual, and then I became a Quaker, which in my meeting, has few rules and is more about each person's individual journey. I love hearing about others' journeys. That's the best ministry I can find.
I love this post! I share a lot of your beliefs and feelings about religion and spirituality. When I was in college I took an Eastern Philosophy class and learned a lot about Buddhism. As you stated, writing about God is a very touchy subject but I think you handled it really well.
ReplyDeleteI thinκ thіs is among the moѕt imрortаnt
ReplyDeleteinfо foг mе. And i'm glad reading your article. But should remark on few general things, The site style is great, the articles is really great : D. Good job, cheers
my web-site: Arjun Kanuri